Sales Pitch
Jim Thome was recently quoted as saying that Mariano Rivera's cut fastball is the single greatest pitch in baseball today, and maybe of all time. Since Rivera is a Yankee, and I refuse to accept any Yankee receiving such high praise, I've decided to poll some drunks at the bar and see who really has the greatest pitch of all time. If you see a West Coast bias, it's because I couldn't afford to travel away from the West Coast to poll drunks in other states. Anyway, I'm gonna divide it by pitch and then further into past and present. If you disagree, go drink some cheap liquor, get hammered, and make yourself available for my next poll.
The Heaters: Surprisingly, I didn't get many Nolan Ryan votes. You would think the ass kicking he gave Robin Ventura a decade or so ago would have boosted his popularity.
Then: Sandy Koufax. The former Dodger southpaw had threw in the mid to high 90s, which is unusual in and of itself for a lefty. In addition to his velocity, he hid the ball in a way that made it impossible for a batter to pick it up out of his hand until it was nearly in the catcher's mitt. Despite elbow problems ending his career very prematurely, Koufax pitched 4 no-hitters.
Now: Rivera. Dammit. As much as I would like to avoid it, it isn't possible. The Yankee closer throws pretty much only one pitch. And that would be the disgusting 95 mph cutter that has confounded hitters for a decade despite the fact that every single one of them knows it's coming. He breaks more opposing hitters' bats per inning than any other pitcher, and is the all-time MLB leader in post-season saves.
Uncles: Much like you can't beat a nice single malt scotch, you can't really hit a great curve ball. I was surprised by the responses I got on this one.
Then: Tie between Nolan Ryan and Dwight Gooden (one drunk each). Both were better known for blazing fastballs, but a lot of guys throw hard. Ryan and Gooden both threw hard, tight-breaking hooks that essentially left hitters helpless, especially if they were waiting for a high 90s smoker. Ryan had 7 career nonos and Gooden had one.
Now: Barry Zito. No contest. Both drunks I asked were in agreement. The A's lefty slings his behind a left handed hitter's ear. While the batter is hitting the deck, trying to avoid being beaned, the ball snaps over the outside corner for a strike. He's been known to hang the occasional one, but if it's on, it's untouchable.
Change: If you throw hard, and then can throw soft with the same arm motion, that makes you good. Seriously.
Then: Tom Glavine. Yeah, he's still active. But the multiple Cy Young Award winner was nearly unhittable 15 years ago. Despite having an above average fastball at best, the former Braves and current Mets hurler pulled the string better than anyone.
Now: It's easy to say Johan Santana or Eric Gagne. Both of them have great changes that make hitters look like idiots much of the time. But the vote goes to Pedro Martinez. Not only does he have a devastating off speed, he throws it deliberately to humiliate hitters rather than just get them out. Pedro is a notorious head hunter, and his change starts right at a left handed batter's chin. While said lefty's life flashes before his eyes, Martinez's change abrubtly slams on the breaks and makes the hitter look like the drunks I talked to.
Slip sliding away: The epitome of the power pitch, only a select few pitchers can really bring this one, as it puts a lot of strain on the arm and each time it's thrown the pitcher runs the risk of blowing his elbow.
Then: Rollie Fingers. The former AL relief champ was the first guy, according to the lushes, one of whom is passed out drooling on himself, to really use the slider as something other than a showcase pitch to change the batter's eye level. It looked like a fastball until veering sharply down and to the left leaving the batter flailing at nothing but air.
Now: The Big Unit. Granted, Randy Johnson doesn't throw as hard as he used to. But his mid to high 80s slider is one of the nasties pitches ever thrown on a diamond. Combine the sling shot motion of his arm making it impossible to pick up the ball with the fact that he is nearly 9 feet tall and can practically hand the ball to the catcher and it's a daunting task for any hitter.
The Hybrids: Some pitches aren't thrown by a lot of pitchers, so it makes it hard to compare. Still, they warrant mentioning and you'll see why when you see the names on this list.
Split Finger: Bruce Sutter. The soon to be Hall-of-Famer revolutionized the pitch. Imagine a normal fastball, then imagine it taking a dive toward the dirt as if it suddenly fell off of Niagara Falls. Tough to hit? Try nearly impossible.
Screwball: Fernando Valenzuela. Limited mainly to leftys, and not used by too many because of arm stress, nobody threw a better one than Fernando. It's basically the opposite of a curveball, and the fact that the pitch's movement seems to defy logic doesn't make it much easier.
The Shady Bastards: Remember Ed Harris, the venerable Indians pitcher from the movie, Major League? Former Cy Young award winner Gaylord Perry had to have been the inspiration for the character. Perry was famous for his spitball. Loading up the ball is strictly forbidden and regarded as cheating. So I guess what I'm saying is, the fact that Perry loaded up nearly every pitch with something and rarely ever got busted is nothing short of phenomenal. Hey, it's only cheating if you get caught!
Knuckler: A misnomer, the knuckler is actually thrown with the index and middle fingernails dug into the seams. A good knuckler doesn't spin, rather it dances. A good knuckleball pitcher will tell you he doesn't even know where it's gonna end up. The greatest ever is probably 50s and 60s relief icon Hoyt Wilhelm. The other great thing about this pitch is that it places virtually no stress on the arm. Phil Niekro and Charlie Hough both pitched into their late 40s using primarily the knuckler.
Yogi Berra once said, "Good pitching will always beat good hitting. And vice versa." I like to say, a good pitch makes you look like a bitch. I don't think that one will catch on... but it's worth a try. Thanks for having a shot of 120Proof.






